Youth unemployment is shaping up as one of the toughest tests for Andy Burnham’s government. According to the Guardian’s headline, Alan Milburn is now pressing the prime minister to commit billions of pounds to a new deal for young people. The call builds on a review that has been rolling out for months.
The Size of the Problem
Milburn has been clear about the problem: “The number of young people who are not in education, employment or training might reach one-in-six by 2031, which represents 1.25 million people.” His interim report released in May suggested that the country may see “a lost generation,” young people poorly prepared to go into the workforce. Burnham is also using hard words to describe the problem, calling it “an economic catastrophe and a moral failure.”
Spending Must Be the Priority
Milburn was quite frank about it being expensive to solve the problem: “It could take a decade and several billion pounds to address this issue. Any blunt approach of slashing funding will simply result in moving young people around in different sections of government accounts.” In the interview with the Financial Times, he mentioned that the solution will cost more money and time to pay back.
What’s in the Plan?
The proposals are varied. The youth opportunity service will operate across all of England by 2029, with each young person having an assigned advisor and individual participation plans. Milburn has also maintained that young people have a right to an assurance of a job, training or employment support. For employers, reductions to National Insurance contributions on people younger than 25 years old will be implemented gradually “when economic conditions permit.” Early investments will be made prior to the changes to welfare.
The Hard Part of the Deal
However, the proposal is not entirely sugar-coated. Milburn has maintained that the reforms will not be “free of pain,” while some young people will get less support in terms of a new youth allowance being paid at the normal rate of Universal Credit. Milburn has positioned this as a deal: as the opportunities increase, then so do the responsibilities. Some media sources report that these proposals may unsettle Labour MPs, mentioning a possible rebellion by backbenchers against the reduction in benefits that would finance the job guarantee scheme.
Burnham’s Response So Far
The government has taken the first steps in this direction already. “Burnham has said the reform process will involve the government investing ‘up front in young people.’ In July, he launched technical education pathways for 14-year-olds, together with up to £8,000 support for small businesses hiring young apprentices.” It is yet to be seen, however, if the Treasury will agree to fund the amounts that Milburn believes necessary. As one observer comments, “the Budget will be the true test because technical education is meaningless with youth unemployment.”
What to Watch Next
There are three key issues that will determine its success. The first one is whether Burnham accepts the whole cost or a reduced version. The second one is the reaction of Labour MPs to the changes in benefits introduced by the package. Finally, the third issue is the reactions of employers to the incentive provided. Youth unemployment has now become as much a political problem as an economic one.




